top of page

Abortion, Formula Milk, and Denial of Work Access for American Women

23 mai 2022

5 minutes

Valerie Beaudoin

Expert on American politics


Our columnist Valérie Beaudoin, expert on American politics

Although the first two elements of the title seem to be in opposition to each other, in reality they were both contributing factors in access to the job market. True 50 years ago, still true today.

Roe v. Wade at the heart of the debates

The leak of a document in the Politico media outlet in April sent shockwaves through the United States, but also here in Canada, where the debate over abortion rights, which was thought to be over, is once again in the hot seat. Roe v. Wade is the landmark decision that guarantees the constitutional right to choose… and it dates back to 1973! The Supreme Court is reportedly on the verge of overturning it.

Beyond the social, moral and health repercussions on women, this possible return to a world where access to the procedure is limited (see criminal), could have significant economic repercussions.



(

You may also like

)

Chronic

BACK TO THE… PAST

If you follow the American news at all, you have most certainly...

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

Chronic

SOCIAL REFORM IN THE UNITED STATES | OVER-AMBITIOUS PROMISES?

Joe Biden has just completed his first year as President of the United States and despite several...

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

Article

ATIKUSS AND THE BOOTS OF HOPE, INDIGENOUS PRIDE

Culture is a reflection of our identity. It transmits a heritage and gives meaning to the past.

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Valérie Beaudoin is an analyst and columnist on American politics. She covers various issues in this society, which often have an impact on us. She is also an associate researcher at the Raoul-Dandurand Chair's Observatory on the United States and a member of the Political Communication Research Group at Université Laval.

Valérie Beaudoin has been analyzing American politics for various Quebec media outlets since 2015, including Radio-Canada, Noovo and 98.5.

During her academic career, she focused her energy on the United States in addition to going there regularly to do field research, whether to cover an election, a swearing-in or various demonstrations across the country.

She enjoys covering various issues in American society that have an impact on us. She is particularly interested in the presidency, elections and the media.

In addition to her work as an analyst and columnist, Valérie is an associate researcher at the Raoul-Dandurand Chair's Observatory on the United States and a member of the Political Communication Research Group at Université Laval.

VALERIE BEAUDOIN

ABOUT


Many researchers agree that the 1973 decision had an impact on the labor market. Indeed, women made up 43% of the workforce in 1970; today, they are more than 57%: that's more than half !

Having the power to choose, women were able to complete their education, avoid being in poverty with a newborn often without any social safety net, and so on.

If the decision is overturned, at least half of the states are expected to ban or severely restrict access to abortion. For wealthy women, this change would mean traveling to another state to have the procedure. For women in precarious situations, without the financial means to pay for travel and to cover missed work, it would be catastrophic.


Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen even recently said that there will be clear economic consequences for affected women. It is also worth remembering that access to child care is already extremely difficult and that there are no regulations to financially support women who wish to take maternity leave. As I wrote in a previous column , companies are not required to provide benefits in this regard.



Milk shortage


What about baby formula? There is currently a shortage of baby formula to the point where when a store's shelves aren't empty, customers are being asked to ration their milk. Supply chain issues , labor shortages and a plant closure in Michigan are just a few of the factors behind the problem.

The situation is so dire that President Joe Biden has invoked a Cold War-era law to ramp up formula production and has also created an airlift to get milk from overseas! The situation is a serious public health issue, but it is also holding back many mothers who want to return to the workforce. With little or no maternity leave, they return to work when their toddler is often still breastfeeding or simply needs formula.



Companies are getting involved


Since April, there has been enormous pressure on American companies to take a stand on abortion rights and denounce this possible step backwards. Some have spoken out and some have even offered to pay the travel expenses of employees who need to have a procedure outside the state where they work. Among them: Apple, Amazon, Bumble, Yelp, Citigroup, Airbnb and Levi Strauss, etc. The Quebec author and journalist, Liz Plank, asked American companies, in an article in Fortune , to take a stand immediately as they have done in the past.

Whether it is for same-sex marriage, Black Lives Matter , trans rights or even the denunciation of restrictions on the right to vote in certain southern states of the United States, several have publicly opposed it.



According to her, their "enthusiasm" to speak out is seriously behind schedule. If a similar situation were to occur in Quebec, it would be interesting to see how businesses would position themselves. What happens on the other side of the border is often a sign of what could happen here.

With the job shortage, this other issue of infant formula is likely to make an already difficult situation worse. When will there be social reform? A question I still ask. Although the situation is far from perfect in Quebec, we are much luckier than some of our American neighbours. However, we must not take this for granted. Women and work, a fragile subject that cannot be avoided and that deserves to be constantly reviewed and corrected.

bottom of page